Palazzo Spada, Rome, seat of the Council of State. Photo: Gobbler, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Every so often a clever route round the law is proposed for the Parthenon sculptures: a loan that quietly becomes a gift, a deposit with no end date, a decree that turns a museum object into something a government can hand over. Italy is often cited as the place where this has already been done. So it is worth setting out what Italian law permits and what it forbids, quoting the Italian where the words matter.
Public collections are cultural property
The starting point is the Cultural Heritage Code (Legislative Decree no. 42 of 2004). Article 10 defines as cultural property (beni culturali) the movable and immovable things belonging to the State, the regions and other territorial public bodies "che presentano interesse artistico, storico, archeologico". It then lists, among other things, "le raccolte di musei … delle regioni", the collections of regional museums. An archaeological object owned by a region and kept in a regional museum is cultural property under the Code, with no further declaration needed.
Inalienable: they cannot be sold or given away
Two provisions close the door on disposal. The Civil Code, article 823(1), lays down the general rule for public property: "I beni che fanno parte del demanio pubblico sono inalienabili". Public-domain property cannot be sold or given away. The Cultural Heritage Code, article 54(1)(c), is more specific: "Sono inalienabili … le raccolte di musei, pinacoteche, gallerie e biblioteche".
There is one opening, and it is narrow. Under article 54(3), these goods "possono essere oggetto di trasferimento tra lo Stato, le regioni e gli altri enti pubblici territoriali". The object stays in Italian public hands; the Code provides no route for giving a museum collection to a foreign state or a foreign institution.
Declassification does not make an object ordinary
Could an administration take an object out of the public domain first and dispose of it afterwards? The Council of State, Italy's highest administrative court, has dealt with the underlying question. In judgment no. 2278 of 22 April 2010 (sixth section), it held that cultural interest is "un carattere intrinseco della res", a quality inherent in the thing itself, and "tendenzialmente insuscettibile di risultare influenzata … dalle vicende relative all'instaurazione o alla cessazione del carattere di demanialità".
Put simply, leaving the public domain does not stop an object being cultural property. A decree can move it from one legal category to another; it cannot remove the archaeological or historical interest that made the object worth protecting, and the protections attached to that interest stay with it.
Permanent export is prohibited
This matters because of article 65(1) of the Code: "È vietata l'uscita definitiva dal territorio della Repubblica dei beni culturali mobili indicati nell'articolo 10, commi 1, 2 e 3". The cultural property defined in article 10, which includes public museum collections, may not leave Italy for good. Temporary export for exhibitions and loans is allowed, under licence and for a fixed term. Permanent export of such objects is barred.
The Code also says what happens when its prohibitions are ignored. Article 164(1): "Le alienazioni, le convenzioni e gli atti giuridici in genere, compiuti contro i divieti stabiliti dalle disposizioni del Titolo I della Parte seconda, o senza l'osservanza delle condizioni e modalità da esse prescritte, sono nulli." The operative word is nulli. A sale, an agreement or any other legal act made in breach of these rules is void and produces no legal effect.
A temporary export has to come home
Since 23 March 2022, the criminal law has covered the end of a loan as well as its beginning. Article 518-undecies of the Penal Code, introduced by Law no. 22 of 2022, punishes illicit export with two to eight years' imprisonment and a fine of up to €80,000. Its second paragraph applies the same penalty to anyone who "non fa rientrare nel territorio nazionale, alla scadenza del termine, beni culturali … per i quali siano state autorizzate l'uscita o l'esportazione temporanee". Parliament plainly regards a loan that does not return as a serious matter.
The international frame
Italy is not alone. The 1970 UNESCO Convention, to which both Italy and Greece are parties, recognises in article 13(d) "the indefeasible right of each State Party to this Convention to classify and declare certain cultural property as inalienable which should therefore ipso facto not be exported", and the right to recover such property if it is exported. Article 3 treats as illicit any export or transfer of ownership carried out contrary to the rules a state adopts under the Convention.
There is an irony here. Inalienability is the foundation of the international system that restitution campaigners invoke whenever they want an object back. It cannot be a sacred principle when it supports a claim and an inconvenience when it stands in the way of a gift.
What is possible, and what is not
The rules leave little room for invention.
Italian law allows:
- transfers of public collections between the State, the regions and local authorities;
- temporary export under licence, for a fixed term, followed by return;
- loans abroad on those terms, including lawful renewals.
Italian law does not allow:
- the sale or gift of museum collections to anyone outside Italy's public bodies;
- the permanent export of public cultural property;
- declassification used to turn cultural property into something that can be given away;
- a temporary export that never comes back.
Why this matters in Britain
Anyone who presents an Italian arrangement as a template for London should first explain how it fits within these rules. Whether a particular transfer complied with them is for the Italian authorities and courts to decide. The general point does not depend on any single case. A legal system that declares its public collections inalienable, forbids their permanent export and voids any act made against those prohibitions offers no shortcut to anyone. It offers the opposite: a reminder that museums hold their collections in trust under law, and that the law cannot be set aside because the cause is popular.
Sources
- Cultural Heritage Code, Legislative Decree no. 42 of 22 January 2004, arts. 10, 54, 65 and 164: Normattiva.
- Civil Code, art. 823: Normattiva.
- Penal Code, art. 518-undecies, in force from 23 March 2022 (Law no. 22 of 9 March 2022): Normattiva.
- Council of State, sixth section, judgment no. 2278 of 22 April 2010.
- UNESCO Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural Property, 14 November 1970, arts. 3 and 13(d); ratified by Italy (Law no. 873 of 1975) and Greece (Law no. 1103 of 1980).


0 Comments